Consumer Reports Annual Auto Issue: The Good, The Bad, And The Green | The Truth About Cars …. Top fuel economy scorers: Prius (44mpg), the oxymoronically-named Smart ForTwo Passion (39), which is also the slowest car to 60 mph, (14.6 sec ), Honda Insight EX (38), VW Golf TDI manual (38), Civic Hybrid (37), Fusion hybrid (34) and on down through several others to the Mini manual (33). Best values, in order: Fit, Prius, Golf (2.5), Civic EX, Jetta TDI, Elantra SE, …